Want to pay your bill? Call 1-877-229-2273 to speak with a Customer Service Representative or click here to securely make your payment online.. Contact us about myBayCare. Visit our Contact Us page for myBayCare questions. Or call: toll-free 1-855-642-6903 to speak with our myBayCare staff.. Urgent Medical Matters. Please do not use myBayCare to send any messages requiring urgent attention..